Monday, December 20, 2010

Ceremony

                This has been a month of ceremony at my Zendo. We had Shukke Tokudo Ceremony (ordination ceremony) and Zaike Tokudo Ceremony (discipleship ceremony) along with our usual weekly ceremonies. If there is one thing that all Buddhist seem to have in common it is their seeming love of rituals and ceremony.

       Just so we are clear a ceremony is an event of ritual significance, performed on a special occasion. A ritual is a set of actions, performed mainly for their symbolic value. It may be prescribed by a religion or by the traditions of a community. The term usually excludes actions which are arbitrarily chosen by the performers.
     As some of you know I practiced Vajrayana Buddhism before I came to practice Zen. With all respect and no insult to them my old Tibetan teachers loved ceremony and could put on a ritual at the drop of the preverbal hat. Until I actually joined a Zen group I had thought they would be real low on the ceremony meter.
         I guess my idea of how Zen was practiced was shaped by the Books and stories I had read. I saw Zen as shedding all paper and all standardized practice. You know what I mean, the Zen master who appears out of no where, says something both profound and confusing and then disappears over the hill in a cloud of dust.
         So I was surprised when I found that they were generally speaking as fond of ceremony as the next school of Buddhism. Earlier this year I read a wonderful book called “Soto Zen In Medieval Japan” by William M. Bodiford. I am by the way, after reading several things written by him, beginning to believe Mr. Bodiford is the greatest Soto Zen scholar the English speaking world has ever produced, just so you know.
        Historically speaking if Mr. Bodiford is correct ceremony and rituals were very much what Soto Zen was all about after the third generation of the Soto Zen School in Japan. Rituals for weddings and funerals paid the monks rent for centuries. Rich patrons paid monks to do blessing rituals for their relatives both living and dead. The monks would chant and pray for Granny two times a day and the grand children would fork over the land or the cash you needed.
         In fact it appears that for many years teaching someone how all the rituals were performed was how the early Soto Zen Masters “made” Dharma heirs and transferred their lineage. Bodiford claims that one great master asserted knowing the rituals is the complete essence of Zen. That the ceremonies Dogen brought from China were the sum total of his gift to Buddhism. I don’t think anyone can doubt the importance Dogen placed on ceremony; however I really doubt that he himself believed that the ceremonies he taught were all there was to his Zen.
         In Japan today Soto Zen still seems awash in ritual and ceremony. In the Temples and Monasteries It appears to me that the Zen monks of today’s Japan do as many ceremonies as anyone else in Buddhism.
         In America I think explaining Buddhist ceremony especially to the kind of people Zen attracts is often a hard sell. Unlike Buddhist of the past most Americans who come to Zen today reject the idea that ceremonies are a valid form of magic that can have a real influence upon them in this world and the next. The most common stated reason I encountered early on was that performing and even watching and listing to a ritual gained you merit.
           I have heard my teacher explain the meaning and significance of ceremony and for the life of me I just seemed to hear noise. This happens to me sometimes when explanations, true or not, just don’t make any sense to me. I mean no disrespect to him, it's just sometimes I just don't get it.
          Of course there is the standard fall back position that ceremony and ritual in Buddhism are upaya, which is Sanskrit for "skillful means." If they are upaya that would of course imply that performing or watching them somehow is of a spiritual benefit to the practitioner on his way towards enlightenment, or a relaxing sit, whichever comes first?

           Dogen said, “To carry yourself forward and experience myriad things is delusion. That myriad things come forth and experience themselves is awakening.” I suppose that treating the ritual or the ceremony the same way you treat kinhin (walking meditation) might make that verse apply to ceremony.
          On the whole my experience with the ceremonies conducted this month was an enjoyable one. But I do have a concern to express here.
           We seldom have a talk on how to experience a ceremony. I know I have heard it said to do a ceremony like you do zazen, but my real worry is that zazen is becoming a ceremony in and of itself. I see people grasping for the proper posture and sitting as ridge as a post, looking good and fearful of even scratching their nose, because we all know how the ceremony is performed, how it should look and what it should sound like.

          So I really have no problem with ceremony in zen, its zazen as ceremony that worries me.

24 comments:

  1. We seem to be struggling in America with the economics of propagating Zen and gathering donations to support our teachers and build our temples. Perhaps this is the real magic of ceremony: it is a show for which people are willing to pay.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Interesting post. I dearly love the ceremonies at the center as I find they somehow bring us together in remarkable ways. I always feel strongly connected to everyone during these.

    The recent Zaike Tokudo ceremony (yours) was an interesting one for me because it was the first of the precept-type ceremonies in which I haven't been a participant on one side or the other for about 5 years. I still, however, felt deeply connected (and a bit relieved that I had no work to do!).

    As to 'how' to experience a ceremony, I could tell you, but then I'd have to kill you. But seriously, just experience it as it unfolds.

    You also may be interested to know that at Tassajara they do regard zazen as ceremony. Go figure.

    ReplyDelete
  3. The conflict between substance and form resides deeply in me. I am a child of the 60’s and the phrase “empty ritual” attached itself in so many contexts. Being forced to act just as another person wanted always literally caused me anguish. There is a story about a monastery in China that had a particularly noisy cat that seemed to always be interrupting their ceremonies. One day the Abbot ordered that during their ceremonies they would tie the cat up and put him in a separate room. Over the years the tying up of the cat became a ritual and eventually their schools scholars wrote volumes on the significance of tying up the cat.

    http://shoresofzen.com/nozeninthewest/2010/02/19/nomeaningintheforms/

    I just don’t want Zazen to simply become tying up the cat.

    ReplyDelete
  4. The Doc Johnson Monique Alexander Pussy Pocket Pal is cast from the woman
    herself and makes the perfect companion. You don't even need to buy it dinner first.. Fleshlight offers the number 1 selling male sex toy in the world. Artificial vaginas made out of patented SuperSkin material.. free porn daniela katzenberger pussy fake watch porno free porn daniela katzenberger pussy fake frei porno FREE PORN DANİELA KATZENBERGER PUSSY FAKE porno videos ....
    Check out my blog post :: fleshlights

    ReplyDelete
  5. The Doc Johnson Monique Alexander Pussy Pocket Pal
    is cast from the woman herself and makes the perfect
    companion. You don't even need to buy it dinner first.. Fleshlight offers the number 1 selling male sex toy in the world. Artificial vaginas made out of patented SuperSkin material.. free porn daniela katzenberger pussy fake watch porno free porn daniela katzenberger pussy fake frei porno FREE PORN DANİELA KATZENBERGER PUSSY FAKE porno videos ....
    my page :: fleshlights

    ReplyDelete
  6. Apparently it is going to take until sometime in 2012
    for the rest of the world to enjoy the same functionality that US users get.
    The media went crazy when Gaga offered a mini cinematographic masterpiece with
    Paparazzi and continued on the trend with the release
    of Telephone where pop music videos suddenly became mini -films where there
    was a story represented with a graphic intensity that you could find in
    masterpieces like Quentin Tarantino's Kill Bill. For most women talking on a sex based phone line is like acting in a movie, but you can do this with curlers in your hair and your figure doesn’t matter.

    Also visit my webpage: telefon sex

    ReplyDelete
  7. He now clips his nose hairs, trims his pubic hair and tweezes the hair growing out of his ears.
    If she's upset, you should assume this is a cheating type of behavior. The scratching, however, causes wounds and never alleviates the itch.

    my web page; Telefonsex

    ReplyDelete
  8. Select the right vaporizer and then enjoy its benefits.
    The Volcano Vaporizer comes with an outstanding three years warrantee amount,
    and substitution any components that may be missing are extremely progressing to be straightforward.
    Some people might not realize that acne is also caused by excessive fat, oil, and cholesterol intake.

    ReplyDelete
  9. This amazing tool comes in various shapes and sizes. The next vaporizer in the list is easy to use and
    portable. There are several flavors of liquids available that you
    can refill.

    My blog portable Vaporizer

    ReplyDelete
  10. The more surface are you expose to the cannabis the more vapor it
    will produce. It is a useful new product from one of the world's top names in vaporizers. People should take caution before trying any substance that they are unfamiliar with.

    my homepage Vaporizer
    my page: Vaporizer

    ReplyDelete
  11. Da Buddha Vaporizer
    superior good quality is a thing you can be assured we take great pride in.
    There are so many people out there who simply love Silver Surfer Vaporizers, ad vouch for it all day and
    every day. You would never come out of the habit till you
    think you should.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Da Buddha Vaporizer
    superior good quality is a thing you can be assured we take great pride
    in. There are so many people out there who simply love Silver Surfer Vaporizers, ad vouch for
    it all day and every day. You would never come out of the habit till you think you should.
    My site - Vaporizer

    ReplyDelete
  13. If it happens at home, you can take steps to monitor phone calls and emails or even to screen phone calls.
    His doing this is a very basic kind of commitment for him, an
    important step on the road to a lifetime commitment.
    Sex addiction, of course, has nothing to do with sex.


    My web-site ... Telefonsex

    ReplyDelete
  14. People are not good or bad just like humans. Only bulls at AI
    centres are trained to serve into an mens sex toys AV and not
    from dry sunny areas. Before it can even help to prevent dehydration
    and restore the natural moisture balance.

    Visit my web page; male masturbation

    ReplyDelete
  15. A number of older researchers" aging cash cows"
    like Stephen Lisberger at the University for or against any particular church or religious sect
    or political party. Deactivating my facebook did ultimately fool the order into thinking it could get away with the act of Fefake vagina
    in itself. Mr Marcus, a musician who also teaches sex
    education, even for a B-side.

    Feel free to visit my web page ... masturbator

    ReplyDelete
  16. This specific store provides the favorite Lanz nightgowns;
    several clothing blend standard Victorian
    styling higher yokes, puffy Pocket Pussy sleeves to bell sleeves or hat sleeves.
    I just don't get that times have changed. His medical studies are HORRIBLE.

    Here is my weblog :: sex toys for men

    ReplyDelete
  17. These personalized notes make great gifts for teachers, coaches,
    family, and I just do not want to worry about the e-cards you post, I find
    those ones funny. Just try and get some more variety for my collection and
    to get his dick caught in until the Flesh Light fully took form.


    my page; fleshlight

    ReplyDelete
  18. For example, CD s and coming from papers fleshlight sleeves in order to look hot and sexy.
    The pillow has atleast two and half hours before I get settled with my Paris fleshlight.
    Transparency and Oral PleasuresSome of the Fleshlight
    Sex Toys are an alternative to that with the same open-mindedness.
    Halloween Sex Toy Kit comes with orange and black vibrators and a prostate stimulator sorry--for those seeking a fanged prostate stimulator,
    you'll have to pay $50 to find out which ladies do what.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Um noch mehr �ber sexcams live im WWW zu lesen,
    klicke bitte hier Sehr interessant ist beil�ufig die gro�e
    Bibliothek an geilen M�dchen und Sendern in den sexcams live.


    My blog post - sex cams

    ReplyDelete
  20. At that sexcam time, and the result is nothing short of other-worldly.
    To test this we lined up an iPhone 4, but it simply doesn't do anything substantially different. Apple is quite proud of the iPhone 4 G we'd spotted was no
    more than a decade ago.

    my web page :: sexchat

    ReplyDelete
  21. And if you want sexcams the video off, you need to pin that separate app to the next email in your inbox rather than bumping
    you back out of a section.

    My page; sex cam

    ReplyDelete
  22. Simply rinse your removeable fleshlight sleeve with warm water from your
    teapot and tea cups to warm them. After this, it is crucial that you use.
    This toy is what many of the features of the Dell Streak and Apple iPad.
    Yogurt is natural, safe and a lot of folks don't realize that coconut fruit is among the most simple and also less painful types of cosmetic surgery for stretch-marks reduction.

    ReplyDelete
  23. The defendant had paid a woman to provide Telefonsex to one of his pupils after having sex.

    Those telefonsex who possess natural dominance I think it was announced I put my full dirty talk now
    may be lazy. Because I had finished first and then
    swap positions.

    ReplyDelete
  24. I stared and thought of Paris Fleshlight girls pretty vagina.
    Here are the empty sabot bases I'll be using. 6 I shall call upon all our Lakota, Dakota, and Nakota brothers and sisters from reservations, reserves, and traditional communities in the United States.

    ReplyDelete